Also consider the Esperanza down there..they just finished a complete upgrade/renovation...I think the resort is more romantic, better food and the new spa is incredible.

The Esperanza is lovely...romantic...quiet...rose petals in the bath await your arrival..chips and dip in the afternoon...something different every day of your stay. I love it.

Also consider Pueblo Bonito Sunset Beach. It's kind of more secluded and it has a gorgeous private beach. OR, go for the beach bed packages at Pueblo Bonito Pacifica.